Direct insurance vs Retail insurance: What does it mean for you?

28 April 2021

As a financial planner, a situation we commonly come across is seeing clients who have purchased Life insurance or Income Protection insurance over the phone from an insurer who has advertised on TV.

It is always an interesting conversation to have to find out why they chose to go down that avenue rather than getting advice from a Financial Planner and generally the answer is the same, time and cost.


The questions that I ask my clients are the following:


  • Did you read the fine print to understand if there are any exclusions?
  • Why did you choose that level of cover?
  • Did you consider any other types of insurance cover ie: Life, Total & Permanent Disability Critical Illness or Income Protection cover?
  • Did you consider cover for your partner/significant other? Who will look after your children if something was to happen to them?


Income Protection is the insurance that clients make the biggest mistakes when purchasing through direct insurance because they don’t understand what the features and benefits mean. They might finish their 30 minute phone call and be set up on an income protection policy that is paid out for 2 years with a 90 day waiting period without understanding that this means if they are off work with an injury or illness they need to be able to self-fund for 120 days before they receive their first payment from the insurer.


Where clients really lose out with direct insurance is by not reading the fine print. When initially applying for direct insurance off the TV, the insurer will go through far less questions than if the client was applying for retail insurance through their Financial Planner and this is where the problem begins. You can ask any client that has been through underwriting with a retail insurer and they will tell you that they poked and prodded in all aspects of their medical history compared to a direct insurer who will only ask you around 10 questions.


Retail insurers are upfront and will tell you about any exclusions upfront whereas direct insurers have a “pre-existing health conditions” warning in their fine print that advises any medical condition that existed 5 years before you took the policy out will be automatically excluded.


While it is great to have some form of insurance, it is important to be covered in all instances for example you may take Income Protection but have you considered Critical Illness cover? A Financial Planner will be able review your entire circumstance and make sure you have the correct insurance with the correct amount of cover.


To protect your and your family’s future and ensure the correct amount of coverage in any situation, please book in a time to speak to us. One of most satisfying feelings as a Financial Planner is knowing you’re able to remove some of the burden from your client’s shoulders by processing claims for them and they can focus on their recovery.


Tamara Vawdrey, Associate Financial Planner at M Group

Tamara Vawdrey

Associate Financial Planner

Mulcahy & Co Financial Planning, Ballarat. 

Latest News

Award Winning Mortgage Brokers
1 December 2025
We’re thrilled to announce that five of our M Group brokers have made the Victorian Excellence List for 2025 for aggregator LMG. This milestone puts our brokers in the top 10% of brokers in VIC and TAS , a reflection of their outstanding performance, and commitment to their clients, with over $50M in settlements or more than 150 loans written in 2025. • Neil McCahon • Warren Freeman • Liam Nankervis • Evette Turlan • Chris Dwye r They've all earned this through hard work, strong relationships, and a relentless focus on helping clients. We are all incredibly proud of their efforts and those of their support team inside our Lending division. To talk to one of our award winning brokers about your home, commercial or business equipment loan, go to: https://www.mgroup.partners/lending-team Click images below for larger versions.
Liam Nankervis announced as Partner
12 November 2025
We are excited to announce that Liam Nankervis is now a partner with the M Group. Liam works with our Lending team as a Finance Broker in our Geelong office and has been with M Group for over 6 years.
Introducing M Group (Formerly Mulcahy & Co)
31 October 2025
After 27 years of dedicated service as Mulcahy & Co, we are proud to unveil the next evolution of our business: M Group.
Sperannuation tax changes for large balances
by Adam Foale 15 October 2025
The government has announced it will make some practical changes to its proposed tax changes for people with large super balances (over $3 million) that will now take effect from 1 July 2026.
Show More